Discover the Best Pizza on Amelia Island 

Your getaway to Amelia Island is one that’s sure to be filled with sand, sun, and surf, but it’s also an experience in amazing flavors! When cravings come calling during your stay and you find that nothing would hit the spot quite like a delicious slice, the following are just a few of the many best pizza Amelia Island spots to pick and choose from.  

Start planning your next trip with our exclusive Amelia Island Vacation Guide! This complimentary resource hosts top recommendations from our innkeepers, including even more Amelia Island pizza stops to check out. When you stay at The Addison on Amelia Island, you’re never far from incredible eateries, so be sure to bring your appetite along for the adventure. 

V Pizza

When you’re traveling with the entire family in tow and looking for a pizza stop with something for everyone to enjoy, V Pizza has what you’re searching for. Located at 2709 Sadler Road in Fernandina Beach, V Pizza offers guests easy access to indoor and outdoor seating, a robust menu, and friendly service too. They’re open from 11:00 am until l10:00 pm Monday through Saturday with adjusted hours on Sundays from 10:00 am until 9:00 pm. This family-friendly stop is one of the best pizza joints in Fernandina Beach and has a menu of custom-topped pizza options as well as wings, salads, sandwiches, pastas, calzones, stromboli, and desserts to order up when you drop by. There’s also a full kids’ menu so even the pickiest eaters in your crew will find something to curb that craving. 

Arte Pizza 

Yet another terrific pizza place to check out during your Amelia Island stay is Arte Pizza located at 109 N 3^rd Street in Fernandina Beach. This locale is loved by locals and visitors alike for its wood-fired pies as well as the welcoming interior, friendly service, and impressive lineup of beer options. You can pick and choose from indoor and outdoor seating when you swing by to enjoy a slice between 11:00 am and 8:30 pm Sunday through Thursday, or 11:00 am and 9:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays. Pizza, pasta, and salad are all on the menu at this welcoming eatery which also caters. Pairing your plate with sides of mozzarella sticks, bruschetta, cheesy garlic bread, or caprese is always highly recommended when you’re here. 

First Love 

For beer aficionados looking to pair their passion with one of the best pizza stops on Amelia Island, time at the First Love Brew Pub is sure to inspire. You’ll find First Love at 22 S 8^th Street in Fernandina Beach and they’re open Wednesday through Friday from 4:00 pm until 9:00 pm as well as Saturday from noon until 9:00 pm and Sundays from noon until 7:00 pm. The pizza dough at First Love is made right in-house and menu options range from the classic Margarita and cheese to specialty pies like Garden Party, The Huli, Buffalo Chicken, and Hot Honey.  

Coastal Pizza 

If you’re spending time at the Island Walk Shopping Center, plan on taking a break to refuel at Coastal Pizza. Located at 1916 S 14^th Street in Fernandina Beach, Coastal Pizza is great to stop by Tuesday through Saturday between 11:00 am and 9:00 pm or on Sundays from 11:30 am until 9:00 pm. Traditional pizza selections here are always hand-tossed, topped fresh to order, and stone-baked too. They have a variety of special pizzas on their menu alongside entrees like mushroom ravioli, chicken parmesan, fettuccine alfredo, and lasagna. Salads and calzones are also readily available to enjoy, and you won’t want to leave without trying their lemon mascarpone cake or ordering cannoli to go. 

Unwind in Style on Amelia Island at the Addison on Amelia